 |
| Avant
is providing the following list of frequently asked questions to assist
hospitals evaluating international nurse recruitment as a part of
their overall staffing solution. This list has been compiled from
a variety of resources including hospital nursing administrators and
human resource professionals who have used foreign trained nurses
at their facilities. This list will be updated periodically so please
check back. |
|
What
are some of the most important issues to evaluate prior to beginning
international nurse recruitment?
Why
is retention so important?
What
types of activities can my hospital do to transition and retain
foreign nurses?
What
international nurse recruitment options are available to me?
What
are the differences in these options?
What
are the primary reasons hospitals decide to work with a recruitment
company?
Some
hospitals choose direct recruitment as a means of saving money on
contract fees. Why does this often times not result in an overall
financial savings?
Why
have some hospitals been very successful at direct international
recruitment and others have not?
Why
would my hospital select long-term contracts as a method of international
nurse recruitment?
Is
selecting an experienced recruitment company important?
Why
is preparing for culture shock so important?
What
steps can be taken to minimize culture shock?
My
hospital has ethical concerns about foreign nurse recruitment. What
information can be provided to address and alleviate the concerns?
|
|
|
What
are some of the most important issues to evaluate prior to beginning
international nurse recruitment?
There are three main issues to consider prior to making a commitment
to hire foreign trained nurses. They are long-term retention of
foreign nurses; options and choices available for international
nurse recruitment; and commitment of the hospital or health system.
|
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
Why
is retention so important?
International nurse recruitment should be directed at filling the
hospitals core staff positions. Many foreign trained nurses are relocating
family and would like to settle in your community on a permanent basis.
Planning and preparing for the retention of these nurses from a cultural
and professional perspective is vital. Although no formal studies
have been done, some hospitals that began recruitment of foreign nurses
in the mid and late 1980's report as high as a 50% retention rate
fifteen year later |
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
| What
types of activities can my hospital do to transition and retain foreign
nurses? Education is vital to preparing the various clinical areas
of the hospital to receive foreign trained nurses. The education should
be focused on cultural and practice differences, as well as measures
each staff member can take to acclimate and transition the nurses.
Also, understanding culture shock and the impact it will have on the
foreign nurse and your staff is extremely important. |
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
What
international nurse recruitment options are available to me?
Two staffing options are available from recruitment companies
- long-term contract to permanent placement and direct placement.
There also is direct recruitment by your facility as some hospitals
have done primarily from the Philippines. |
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
|
What
are the differences in these options?
The main difference with the recruitment companies will be level
of support, education of your staff and preparation and support
of the foreign trained nurses. Companies that provide nurses on
long-term contracts should have significantly more infrastructure
to coordinate the recruitment process. They also should prepare
the foreign nurses for practice in the US and your hospital. They
should have significant in-house clinical staff that has experience
in transitioning foreign nurses. This is crucial for successful
and timely transitioning. In addition, some of these companies help
family members with transitioning, such as spouses in finding employment,
enrolling children in schools, filing income tax returns, etc.
Companies
that offer nurses on direct placement tend not to have as significant
an infrastructure to coordinate the recruitment process. They may
outsource the immigration and/or licensure process. In addition,
they tend to lack the experience of clinically transitioning the
foreign nurses to US hospitals. This experience is often vital in
selecting nurses and also in preparing the nurse and hospital.
|
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
What
are the primary reasons hospitals decide to work with a recruitment
company?
Most hospitals choose to work with recruitment companies because international
recruitment is not their core competence. They do not want to create
an internal department to handle and monitor the licensure, immigration,
education of in-house staff, clinical transition of foreign nurses,
and social and cultural transition of the nurse and their families.
In addition, they do not want to get involved in dealing with issues
such as finding accommodations, purchasing cars or dealing with establishing
a credit line. |
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
|
Some
hospitals choose direct recruitment as a means of saving money on
contract fees. Why does this often times not result in an overall
financial savings?
There are many reasons why direct recruitment efforts by hospitals
do not always result in lower costs. First is attrition. Many hospitals
choose to go to high supply countries, such as the Philippines and
India. These nurses have high attrition rates and historically lower
pass rates on the NCLEX. Most nurses in the Philippines have signed
employment contracts with several hospitals and/or recruitment companies
and then go with the hospital or company whose visa petition is
approved first. This is starting to become more prevalent in India
as well. Therefore, many nurses the hospital may make initial job
offer to do end up not working for them.
Once
the nurses arrive, some may not be successful in transitioning for
clinical, social or cultural reasons. Reputable recruitment companies
should have replacement clauses for nurses that are not successful
at a hospital. Lastly, if the hospital does not spend time researching
practice differences, creating specialized orientation programs
and preparing its staff, the foreign nurses may take an extended
time to become productive and safe practitioners.
|
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
Why
have some hospitals been very successful at direct international recruitment
and others have not?
Hospitals that tend to be most successful in direct recruitment of
international nurses when they create a department or staff dedicated
to the initiative. In addition, they have knowledge and experienced
nursing staff members to lead the department. This "International
Nurse Recruitment Department" can then be responsible for much of
the preparation, education and activities needed to be successful
in the endeavor. |
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
|
Why
would my hospital select long-term contracts as a method of international
nurse recruitment?
Long-term contract assignments should offer hospitals significant
clinical and transitioning support for the foreign nurses and hospital
staff, replacement clauses for unsuccessful nurses and those who
are just not a good "fit" with the health system. In addition, recruitment
companies should closely monitor the foreign nurses during orientation.
They should have clinical staff available to work with preceptors
or nurse managers to detect and correct any issues that may arise.
In addition, the recruitment company should handle all "non-vocational"
transitioning issues; such assisting spouses find jobs, enroll children
in schools or find appropriate childcare, filing income taxes, establishing
credit and many other issues.
|
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
|
Is
the long-term contract option of international recruitment the most
costly option?
No, not always. In fact it may be the more cost effective in many
ways.
Please
see the answer to "Some hospitals choose
direct recruitment as a means of saving money on contract fees.
Why does this often times not result in an overall financial savings?."
|
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
Is
selecting an experienced recruitment company important?
Yes, very important. Many of the aspects of the international nurse
recruitment process are learned through trial and error. Experienced
companies should use their experience to build its infrastructure,
prepare the nurses and receiving hospitals. |
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
Why
is preparing for culture shock so important?
It is extremely important to understand culture shock and the overt
and subtle impact it will have on the foreign nurse. The phases of
culture shock can take a toll on foreign nurses and their family.
It can lead to physical illness and signs of grieving and/or depression.
|
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
What
steps can be taken to minimize culture shock?
Preparing nurses and their families for culture shock and then closely
monitoring for it can alleviate its impact on the nurse. Educating
your staff, especially preceptors, can help in detecting the subtle
signs of culture shock prior to making a significant impact or in
extreme cases the foreign nurse returning to their home country. |
|
Return
to FAQ index
|
|
My
hospital has ethical concerns about foreign nurse recruitment. What
information can be provided to address and alleviate the concerns?
The International Council for Nurses has released a position statement
on ethical nurse recruitment. The statement can be viewed on their
website or through the link on the Avant home page. There are several
key points to the position statement. They are listed below but
primary focus should be on source countries, recruitment practices
and clinical transitioning support.
ICN
recognises the right of individual nurses to migrate, and confirms
the potential beneficial outcomes of multicultural practice and
learning opportunities supported by migration.
ICN
condemns the practice of recruiting nurses to countries where authorities
have failed to implement sound human resource planning and to seriously
address problems which cause nurses to leave the profession and
discourage them from returning to nursing.
ICN
denounces unethical recruitment practices that exploit nurses or
mislead them into accepting job responsibilities and working conditions
that are incompatible with their qualifications, skills and experience.
|
|
Return
to FAQ index
|